We need to talk about #Bana

Bana is safe now in Turkey, and my dearest wish for her is that she be able to lead a peaceful and happy life. I hope her parents can make that possible.  In this piece I shall not be referring to a little Syrian girl, now 8 and settled in a new country. For her, my heart desires nothing but good things.

I shall be speaking of the internet phenomenon @AlabedBana and of the adults responsible for creating it. To speak of family members is unavoidable.

To start with a simple and quite obvious fact: the @AlabedBana Twitter account was not initiated or run by a 7 year old girl from Aleppo, even if one was used as its living avatar. Some intuitively doubtful elements of the tale – that were defended against ‘conspiracy theorists’ by the corporate media and its penumbra of disinformationists – can now be demonstrated. For since the fighting stopped in Aleppo, some verifiable truth about people, places and events there during the time of the occupation and siege has been coming out. It differs in many ways from what we were encouraged to believe by the massed corporate media of the world. The twitter account @AlabedBana is one conspicuous example. Another is the image of the little boy Omran, who we’ll return to at the end.

What I am going on to write here involves no in-depth research or analysis on my part. That has been done by Khaled Iskif, a journalist from Aleppo. (I commend his video about @AlabedBana and other videos covering previously unrecorded aspects of the situation in Aleppo. He regularly adds videos to his Youtube channel) He lives in the Western part of town that was protected by the government while the Eastern part was held hostage. He is now able to go across and track down various locations that have become familiar to us from the video reports earlier transmitted via the Aleppo Media Center (in Turkey) and onward through the world’s corporate media.

In this latest video, Khaled takes us on a short walk around the Alabed house and environs, accompanied by Nour Al Ali doing the filming and photography. They show us into the Alabed house, and then into the Al Nusra headquarters adjacent to it.

The proximity of the house to the Al Nusra headquarters is demonstrated – each a few meters from a shared street corner. This explains why the house was in an area being bombed. About 100 men were quartered in the basement of the adjacent building, according to a local witness interviewed.

We learn about the Alabed family. The paternal grandfather was running a weapons dealership and repair workshop for Al Nusra and other militant groups; his sons worked there; one of them had served a criminal sentence, even before the war, for gun smuggling; and we are shown a photo of the now famous granddaughter at about 3 years posing with a serious-looking weapon that is as big as her.

Her father Ghassan worked as a lawyer, before joining the armed groups. We see photos of Ghassan, armed, with the militant factions Al Nusra and the Islamic Safwat Brigade. We see documents showing he served in the Sharia Court based in the ‘Eye Hospital’. Admidst other papers strewn about the abandoned house is one that indicates he was ‘assistant director of the Civil Registry of Aleppo Council’ – a “rebel” organisation with links to foreign states and armed groups in the governorate. Another document shows he worked as a military trainer and investigating judge for the Islamic Safwa brigades. Prior to 2015 he had been working with ISIS in the Sharia court in the Eye Hospital. We see a photo of him brandishing an AK47 beneath an ISIS flag; and another of him in the midst of an armed Asafwa group. We see him with four brothers, each holding a serious weapon, outside the store.

Also lying around is a dog-eared piece of paper with one of Bana’s famous #StandWithAleppo messages on.

Outside, and a few steps just around the corner, we are taken into the basement. We are now inside the headquarters of Al Nusra. There we see rolled militant flags, Turkish supplies, and a prison.

On this and the other videos there is much more to see. So I recommend them. They don’t have the slick production values of Channel 4 and the other corporate media outlets. What they do offer is honest and dispassionate testimony.   Or as dispassionate as a participant observer can be under the circumstances.

As a resident of Aleppo, Khaled is visibly affected by the whole situation. He expresses something close to despair about “the exploitation of children in politically motivated attempts to distort the image of his government.” His fellow citizens in that part of town have confirmed on the video that they had been human shields for the militants.

Khaled also has a word about the little boy Omran who, photographed in the orange-seated ambulance, was another major media sensation in the West. We meet Omran today in videos with Khaled (and others, like this and this). He is in Aleppo, back in his original home, not Turkey. He was thrust into the world’s media spotlight against his family’s wishes. His family is glad Aleppo was liberated from the likes of those that made the propaganda for #Bana.



This entry was posted in journalism, media, propaganda, Syria, Uncategorized, war. Bookmark the permalink.

8 Responses to We need to talk about #Bana

  1. M Kavanagh says:

    thank you.
    “Oldest [theatrical?] trick in the book” – where the same phenomena [‘evidence’] suffer a slight of hand and are turned by this presentational context to mean the opposite of what they REALLY mean. Reminds me of the conmen described so wonderfully and in such detail by Mark Twain in Huckleberry Finn. “Working the crowd” at a funeral, to twist the feeling in the room to their ’cause’, their profiteering. These skills are now manifestly afoot – creating false ‘phenomena’ as news, twisted in a ‘flash’, presented -pickpocketed, ‘hijacked’ to ‘mean’ something else- through the MSM as ‘tearjerking narrative’, when the real tears have a different source, and only the canny few are decoding them. The strategies are as old as fraudulence. The audience as gullible as ‘lambs’ [to the slaughter]. The slaughter of truth. The slaughter of laughter for the REAL children of Syria. The slaughter of Innocence. Can we watch the ‘magician’ ..and astutely, perspicaciously, question how it’s done, how the wool is pulled over humanity’s eyes? Thus SEE TROUGH?
    So appreciate your thoroughness Tim, your tenacity, your clarity.

  2. Pingback: Der Fall Bana Alabed – Some Personal Snapshots

  3. Alex Ocana says:

    “. . . we are shown a photo of the now famous granddaughter at about 3 years posing with a serious-looking weapon that is as big as her.”

    May I suggest that you look at this, especially her face, with fotoforensic software? (Noise analysis level 80, then just look at the photo)

    Photos paired for side by side analysis. Left authentic control image. Right from video, easy to see paste on lines. Its IMO a fake with Bana’s face pasted on another child. Repeatable & falsifiable experiment.

    Photo analysis here: https://twitter.com/DominicaCanaPt/status/896901122824093697

    • timhayward says:

      I am not expert in determining whether photos are fake, so if I simply say they don’t look it to me that is hardly evidence of anything, in itself, I realise. The point Khaled makes is that the photo was taken in the gun repair shop, and his whole account does not depend on one photo which is only used to illustrate a point elaborated in detail over several hours of video. If the photo were cut from the footage, nothing else would change.

      (The linked analysis is baffling to this non-expert, and all it does for me is obscure the original photo, which I had to hunt down for the purpose of this reply. I mention this in case any other readers want to follow this up. You can see the original photo I referred to at 06:46 here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B-GXAqsSRMo )

      • Alex Ocana says:

        Now imagine I pasted your face over a picture of some ISIS goon and accused you of being an ISIS goon. Or worse, suppose I posted a picture of your little daughter’s face on another kid holding an assault rifle in white supremacist headquarters and accused you publicly for weeks at a time, over and over again of being a Nazi sympathizer and child abuser. I wouldn’t do it. Its unethical at best, slander of a war child at worst.

        I have done my analysis and posted here the falsifiable results. I’m really sick of this Bana bullying by fascist regime sympathizers. Especially the propensity to falsify information to make Bana look evil.

        Perhaps it would be wiser to look at people like Asma al-Assad who gleefully goes shopping for millionaire shoes, spends millions on palace furniture, and was an employee of JP Morgan before tying the knot with Bashar not to mention paying off USA trained lobbyists to get a nice article in Vogue as “Rose of the Desert”. Oh, and worried about getting a copy of the latest Harry Potter movie. https://twitter.com/DominicaCanaPt/status/896731601366863872 At least she is a filthy rich adult with lots of power (not a kid stuck in a war zone).

        Even better yet is forget these personalities and propagandists who fan the flames of war and start thinking about how negotiations & peace can be established in as short a time possible with the least amount of suffering for all the kids caught up in this and other bloodbaths.

  4. Pingback: Bana and Censorship | Tim Hayward

  5. Pingback: How We Were Misled About Syria: George Monbiot of The Guardian | Tim Hayward

  6. Pingback: How We Were Misled about Syria: George Monbiot of The Guardian | OffGuardian

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s